Nah I figured it out, what happened is this...
My old gamertag got banned on the forza forums, so I made a new one with my new xbox so I could go on there again. After remembering about the cars that get transferred from your old garage to your new one, I went and redid a bunch of stuff in fm3 on my old account (new hard drive, so I had to start over, but still had access to my LCE content). Once I had gotten the cars (Superleggera and Scuderia) I went to transfer them to my new account- that doesnt work because they are not able to be gifted, due to being LCE content...
So I decided that i'd just play the game on my old account, and forget the forza forums, they arent that good anyway.
In doing that, i basically gave up my VIP status, as it was redeemed on my new account, which i dont use, and is only a silver account now, and I dont really want to pay for more gold membership on it, just so I can get that integra. The only way i'd be able to use it is if I share it with the club, and i'm guessing your going to do that with yours anyway?
I am pretty annoyed at myself though, that means I dont get included in the VIP car battles, etc :( I might send T10 a message, see if they can help me out.