Got the game today (PS3 version). I haven't yet played it enough to give it a fair rating, so I won't vote in the poll for now. I'll post some of my first impressions though.
I'll start with the positive stuff. It still feels like good ol' TDU, where you can just get into the car and explore the island. The graphics seem very good.
Now the not-so-positive stuff. The cutscenes are annoying IMO, and to make matters worse they cannot be skipped. Moreover, there's no way to get the GPS to STFU (that or I'm too dumb to find it). It keeps guiding me to the next race when I just want to cruise :fp: The handling also seems to be a problem in faster cars, the Cali felt kinda weird to drive... maybe I'll get used to it though.
Despite the minor annoyances, I'm having fun playing the game, so I'll give it a 7/10 for now.