The "Same Manufacturer "Car .vs. Car"" Thread

[Car Freak]

Very tough decision :(

 

I like the XF's design better as a whole, but I just cannot stand those front headlights! :bananamad: And the SV8 has crap rims...

On the other hand, the idea of an "old-man's car" being able to surprise ricers at the lights really draws me to the XJR. It's so much stealthier than the German super saloons. And looks the sex in black with 20" Sepang alloys. But I just cannot stand the facelift's bumper! Looks like a fat man's chin!

 

So after a lengthy internal debate, I'll take this

A pre-facelift one with those Sepang alloys. Plus, I'll have some money left over to buy something else! :D

[Car Freak]

:bump:

 

BMW M3 E46

OR

BMW Z4M Coupe

 

(Both same-engined you see)

[CarMadMike]

m3 E46 FTW!

[Andreas¹]

I'd rather have... NONE! both are ugly as... on the front :oook: But if I had to choose, M3

[Guest RB26DETT]

M3 E46 is not ugly!!!!

 

I'd take the M3 E46 please. :)

[Baltoman]

M3 defintly... Z4s shoulden't be coupes

[Andreas¹]

M3 E46 is not ugly!!!!

On the front yes, I think so :P

[Turkey Twizzler]

I'll take the M3 too :)

[Who]

*being different*

 

i really like the Z4, wonderful car :D

[Camel]

my mates uncle used to have a Z4 and i had a ride in it, very nice car so i'd go for that

[iBilo]

Z4 ftw.

[ExplosiveGoats]

M3 E46 for me.

[MCW]

M3 E46 but the CS model with the CSL wheels

[Fridge Magnet Rabbit]

Z4 for me, its sexeh

[DriftNismo]

Wayy too easy of a choice, M3 for me :D.

 

I love the Z4M coupes, they're beautiful but they're not on the same level as the E46 M3 :D.

[Car Freak]

*koff koff* It sure is dusty in here...

 

Anyway I know it's been a long time, but with your approval, I'd like to revive this little thread cos it was fun back in the day. And also ask your opinion on something i feel rather strongly about: BMW super-SUVs

 

 

Think the X5M too "Chelsea Tractor-ish"? Or is the X6M too pointless?

 

Personally I'd take the X5 because i really REALLY don't get the point of the X6. But then, there are some out there who think the X6 is great :ill: (I'm looking at you, Mark)

[TDU 505]

6 > 5, which coincidentally is your mental age.

 

Actually i wouldn't mind neither. Like i said, I love any hot BMW, Audi or Merc

[T1M]

X5 :D

 

The X6 is just an uglier, less practical X5 lol

[Who]

deciding what's a nicer SUV is like deciding whether you'd prefer to have heart disease or lung cancer, both options are pretty crap.

[Car Freak]

Wa-hey! In your face, Mark!

[Andreas¹]

If I had to get one of them, I'd get the X6. Looks way better than the X5, I don't care that it isn't practical.

[TDU 505]

If I had to get one of them, I'd get the X6. Looks way better than the X5, I don't care that it isn't practical.

Wa-hey! In your face, Mark!

Wahhey! Back in your's Jon!

[Brad_F430]

r32 for sure, only because i love skylines though

[Car Freak]

Whoa, what? Where did the Skylines pop up? You're supposed to make your choice based on the two cars last posted, which in this case is most definitely not the Skylines

[Andreas¹]

Me thinks he looked at the first page. Anyways, new duel time?