The "Same Manufacturer "Car .vs. Car"" Thread

[Who]

Why wasnt the roadster included in this? i like that car as opposed to the other two.

 

at a push (well, more of a shunt, delivered by a freight train) i would say ForFour

[Guest RB26DETT]

New one.

 

BMW M3 E46 or

http://i139.photobucket.com/albums/q299/turbod_m3/DSC00379.jpg

 

BMW M3 E92

http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t319/Skywalka_2007/wp_bmw_e92-m3_03.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

I'm picking the E46 just because it looks better. ;)

[ExplosiveGoats]

I have to say the E46, it looks more Bold and Furious.

[Car Freak]

If I could, I'd put the E92's V8 into the E46... But seeing as that's cheating, I'll go for the 46

[Aquila DK]

E46 preferably as a CSL :D

[Fridge Magnet Rabbit]

TBH i dont know, the E46 is a nice car but the E92 just looks mean at the front...

im gonna have to say the E46

[Guest RB26DETT]

hahahaha! it's a sweep for the E46 at the moment. just as i would've predicted.

[TDU 505]

Love teh E46 :D

Looks different than the "usual" 3-Serieses

The new one just looks....the same

[Who]

the E92 is ugleh... E46 for me

[Aquila DK]

  RB26DETT said:

hahahaha! it's a sweep for the E46 at the moment. just as i would've predicted.

I don't even like BMW's, but if I were to buy one, I'd be the E46, that's why I chose it :D

[Car Freak]

:bump:

Ok, another one (going for a Q-car theme here)

Mercedes 190E 2.5-16 Cosworth

or

Mercedes E500 (W124)

[Andreas¹]

Cossie :D

[CarMadMike]

Yah the Cosworth

[Guest RB26DETT]

W124 for me. looks a bit more sportier.

[Speedtouch]

Cosworth. Its just the sense that you would get knowing that only a select few would know why you have that car, and like you instantly for it.

[Baltoman]

none, they both loook really ugly to me

[DriftNismo]

The Cossie for me. Thinking about one as a first or second car, you can get very clean manual examples for about £800-1200 on Autotrader :p.

[Car Freak]

Darn, I was hoping more would go for the 500. I like both a lot, and I think the Cosworth looks better (and is rarer), but I just can't say no to a V8 :D

[Fridge Magnet Rabbit]

PEEL P50

 

OR THE PEEL-SOMETHING-OR-OTHER

[Car Freak]

The Something-or-other.

 

1) It really looks like The Jetsons, and 2) everyone's gonna say "P50" because Jeremy made it famous(ish) on TG

[Speedtouch]

I'd have the P50. I just don't like the other one.

[Guest RB26DETT]

those are cars? :eek:

[Car Freak]

Anyway, thought I'd see how far I can bend the rules this week:

 

Skoda Octavia vRS

or

Seat Leon FR (the Cupra is too powerful for this group)

or

VW Golf GTi

 

They aren't the same manufatcturer, but they are all under Volkswagen AG...

[Guest RB26DETT]

hmmmm. Golf GTi for me.

[hesonly5]

Not the same manufacturer!